Top 11 New York Insurance Agency & Brokers
One word that could succinctly describe the landscape of insurance in New York would be change.
With the rise of new challenges and the need for comprehensive coverage, selecting the right insurance agency or broker has never been more important.
Navigating the variety of insurance options available in New York requires a nuanced understanding of the industry and its offerings.
The Value of Choosing the Right Insurance Agency or Brokers
The importance of insurance in providing peace of mind cannot be overstated. A reliable insurance agency or broker offers protection against unforeseen financial losses and acts as a trusted advisor in times of need.
They understand the risks associated with living and working in New York and tailor their services to meet these specific needs. By using their expertise and extensive network of insurers, they can offer competitive rates and comprehensive coverage that extends beyond standard policies.
How to Choose the Right Insurance Agency or Brokers for Your Needs
Identifying the right insurance agency or broker in New York starts with understanding your specific needs and risks. Whether it's for personal insurance, such as home or auto, or business-related coverage, clarity on what you need to protect is the first step.
From there, look for agencies or brokers with a strong reputation in the market, evidenced by positive reviews, industry awards, and years of operation. These indicators often reflect a company's reliability, expertise, and commitment to its clients.
TL;DR Top 11 New York Insurance Agency & Brokers
Alpha Apex Group: Alpha Apex Group in New York offers custom insurance solutions and exceptional service, leveraging its strategic location in a dynamic market to address specific risks for businesses and individuals.
New York Life: A leading mutual life insurance company renowned for prioritizing policyholder interests, offering a wide range of insurance and investment services, and demonstrating a strong commitment to social responsibility through its philanthropic efforts.
New York Choice Insurance Agency: An independent insurance brokerage firm offering a comprehensive array of personal and commercial insurance products through a vast network of carriers, emphasizing client education and satisfaction.
NYCM Insurance: A property and casualty insurance provider with a long history in New York, known for its commitment to exceptional service and security, offering a wide range of insurance options.
Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc.: An independent agency that provides a diverse selection of insurance products from numerous carriers, focusing on tailored solutions and extensive coverage options for a variety of insurance needs.
Crowley Insurance: A family-owned independent insurance agency that offers personalized insurance solutions from top carriers, dedicated to exceptional service and treating clients as part of the family.
Alpha Apex Group, Leaders in New York Insurance.
Alpha Apex Group is recognized as a top-tier insurance agency and broker in New York, renowned for its comprehensive insurance solutions and exceptional client service. Their strategic presence in the heart of one of the world's most dynamic insurance markets allows them to offer tailored policies that address the specific risks and challenges faced by New York-based businesses and individuals.
With a deep understanding of both local regulations and global insurance trends, Alpha Apex Group provides a broad spectrum of insurance products including commercial, personal, and specialty coverages. Their approach combines personalized client consultations with advanced analytics to ensure optimal protection and value.
Key services:
Commercial and personal insurance brokerage
Specialty insurance solutions tailored to unique risks
Risk assessment and management consulting
Policy customization and competitive pricing
Claims advocacy and support services
Why work with Alpha Apex Group:
Alpha Apex Group's expertise and commitment to excellence make them a preferred choice for insurance services in New York. Their dedication to understanding client needs and providing customized solutions ensures that businesses and individuals are not only well-protected but also positioned to manage potential risks effectively and efficiently.
As the nation's largest mutual life insurance company, New York Life places its policy owners at the core of its operations, distinguishing itself from publicly traded companies by not answering to Wall Street but rather to its policyholders.
New York Life Direct caters to consumers directly, while a partnership with AARP underscores its broad reach. Beyond insurance, New York Life Investments, a subsidiary, serves institutional and retail clients globally, managing a diverse portfolio through independent investment boutiques.
New York Life's philanthropic efforts, spearheaded by the New York Life Foundation, concentrate on childhood bereavement and community support, embodying the company’s commitment to social responsibility. This includes partnerships with various organizations to support grieving children and families, demonstrating a holistic approach to business that extends beyond financial services.
Key Services:
Whole Life Insurance
Term Life Insurance
Universal Life Insurance
Long-Term Care Insurance
Annuities
Disability Insurance
Asset Management through New York Life Investments
Why work with New York Life?
New York Life has a storied history of stability, financial strength, and a commitment to putting its policyholders first. Its mutual company status ensures that decisions are made with the long-term interests of policy owners in mind, supported by a legacy of consistently paying dividends and a strong commitment to community and social responsibility.
New York Choice Insurance Agency is an independent insurance brokerage firm, serving a diverse clientele across the New York/New Jersey metropolitan area, and beyond.
This agency differentiates itself by representing over 20 leading local and national insurance carriers, ensuring they offer the best coverage solutions for both personal and commercial insurance needs.
By working with a wide range of insurance providers, New York Choice Insurance Agency can secure discounts and coverage options that might not be readily available to the general public. The agency places a strong emphasis on client education and satisfaction, with experienced staff guiding customers through the intricacies of various insurance policies to find the perfect match for their needs.
Key Services:
Auto Insurance
Classic Car Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
RV/Motorhome Insurance
Business Insurance
Business Owners Package (BOP) Insurance
Workers Compensation
Disability Insurance
Life Insurance
Home Insurance
Condo Insurance
Flood Insurance
Landlords Insurance
Boat Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Why work with New York Choice Insurance Agency?
New York Choice Insurance Agency offers a comprehensive suite of insurance products and prioritizes personalized service and client education. Their affiliation with a vast array of carriers and their commitment to finding you the best possible coverage make them an ideal choice for safeguarding your financial future.
NYCM Insurance is a property and casualty insurance firm centered in New York. With a rich heritage dating back to 1899, it is driven by a commitment to safeguarding its clients' most valued possessions.
The company boasts a robust team of over 800 insurance professionals, offering a comprehensive range of services across New York state. They primarily operate in the property and casualty insurance industry within the state of New York.
Key Services:
Automobile Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Mobile Home Insurance
Condo Insurance
Renters Insurance
Business Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Emergency Roadside Assistance
Why work with NYCM Insurance?
NYCM Insurance is a company that has stood the test of time, evolving to meet the needs of its policyholders while maintaining a core focus on exceptional service and security.
Their long-standing commitment is to protect the things that matter most to their customers, delivered through personalized, quality customer service and a robust array of insurance options.
Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc., is an independent insurance agency, offering a wide range of insurance products thanks to its partnerships with numerous top carriers. This flexibility allows them to cater to diverse insurance needs while providing competitive rates and extensive coverage options.
Unlike captive agencies that only offer products from a single company, Tanner Insurance Agency prides itself on its ability to offer customized solutions that best fit the needs of its clients. Their expertise is not limited to a single insurance product, company, or set of guidelines, which enables them to service policyholders proactively and navigate various insurance scenarios effectively.
Key Services:
Auto Insurance: Coverage includes property damage, bodily injury liability, and uninsured & under-insured liability. Factors like age, credit, car type, driving history, and household composition are considered for premium calculation.
Homeowners Insurance: Offers coverage for dwelling, other structures on the property, personal property, loss of use, medical expenses, family/personal liability, and scheduled personal property.
Personal Insurance: Broad spectrum of personal insurance options including life, specialty dwelling, umbrella, motorcycle, boat, homeowners, auto, renters, ATV & powersports, flood, condo, and recreational vehicle insurance.
Trucking Insurance: Tailored insurance solutions for various types of trucks including tandem tractor, dump combo, box truck, flatbed, moving, and tow truck insurance. They emphasize understanding the unique needs of trucking companies and offer specialized programs accordingly.
Why work with Tanner Insurance Agency, Inc.?
The agency's independence from any single insurance provider allows them to offer a wide array of products and coverage options, ensuring clients receive insurance solutions that are tailored to their specific needs.
Their deep understanding of the insurance industry, combined with the ability to navigate various insurance products and scenarios, makes them a reliable choice for individuals and businesses alike.
Crowley Insurance is an independent insurance agency rooted in East Syracuse, New York, known for its commitment to providing personalized insurance solutions.
Established in 1952 by Bernard M. Crowley after his tenure as a claims adjuster, the agency has flourished over the decades through direct sales and acquisitions, now run by the third generation of the Crowley family.
Their mission is to simplify the insurance process, offering flexible coverage options from a vast selection of top-tier insurance carriers. They pride themselves on delivering exceptional customer experiences, ensuring that clients feel like part of the family.
Notable Features:
Comprehensive coverage for home, auto, business, and more
Personalized service and expert advice
Independent agency with a wide selection of insurance carriers
Key Services:
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Commercial Business Property Insurance
Workers Compensation Insurance
Why work with Crowley Insurance?
Crowley Insurance is a family-owned agency that prioritizes your needs and works diligently to find the best insurance solutions for you. Their deep-rooted commitment, known as "The Crowley Commitment," underscores their dedication to honesty, personal dialogue, and customized service, ensuring you're treated like family and not just another policy number.
7. Schulman Insurance Brokerage
Schulman Insurance Brokerage, an independent insurance advisory firm located in Garden City, NY, prides itself on delivering unparalleled value and personalized service to its clients.
Founded by Jonathan Schulman in 2006, the company has established a significant presence in the insurance industry, showcasing a dedication to providing comprehensive insurance solutions that cater to various needs.
Schulman Insurance offers a range of services, including health, dental, vision, life, and disability insurance, along with pre-tax accounts and PEO services, tailored to both small and large groups.
Their expertise is evident in their ability to navigate the complexities of the insurance marketplace, ensuring their clients receive optimal plans that align with their needs and financial situations.
Key Services:
Health Insurance Coverage for medical and dental expenses
Dental/Vision Insurance
Life Insurance for income protection
Disability Insurance for income protection during long-term disability
PEO Services for both small and large group health insurance
Guidance on ACA compliance and reducing employee benefit costs
Why work with Schulman Insurance Brokerage?
Schulman Insurance Brokerage is a firm that brings a wealth of experience and established carrier relationships to the table and also prioritizes innovative and client-centric solutions.
Their dedication to understanding and addressing the specific needs of their clients, combined with their ability to simplify and effectively manage the insurance process, makes them a valuable ally in securing comprehensive insurance coverage.
8. Integrity Coverage Group
Integrity Coverage Group has been delivering comprehensive insurance solutions and guidance to individuals and businesses for over a quarter of a century since its inception in 1996.
With a focus on forging strong relationships and leveraging vast experience with international corporations, Integrity Coverage Group stands out by offering unique coverages that cater to the specific needs of its clientele.
Operating out of Brooklyn, NY, and licensed in multiple states including DE, NY, PA, MD, IL, and NJ, the group emphasizes personal service combined with the prowess of global operations.
Key Services:
Wide-ranging insurance offerings including personal and commercial auto, workers compensation, disability, contractor services, and more.
Comprehensive DMV services for various needs such as registrations, titles, and safety audit preparations.
Specialized licensing services covering agricultural, alcohol, cigarette & tobacco, among others.
IRS services including Certificate of Authority.
Why work with Integrity Coverage Group?
Integrity Coverage Group combines the reach and expertise of a seasoned player with the personalized care and attention of a local provider.
Their ability to secure specific coverages through well-established relationships, along with a commitment to fair treatment and asset protection at the claim time, makes them a reliable ally in navigating the complex insurance landscape.
9. Honig Conte Porrino Insurance Agency Inc.
Honig Conte Porrino Insurance Agency Inc. (HCP) is well known among businesses and individuals in New York, offering comprehensive insurance solutions.
With roots planted firmly in Manhattan, HCP prides itself on its third-generation heritage, reflecting stability, trust, and deep community ties. Their expert team, many of whom boast over a decade of service, embodies commitment and fosters long-lasting client relationships.
HCP offers personalized service without any cost to the client. They undertake the legwork of shopping for insurance across multiple carriers to ensure clients receive the best value and coverage.
Their approach emphasizes long-term client retention over initial policy sales, highlighting a dedication to satisfaction and service quality. The array of coverages recommended includes Business Owner’s Policy, Workers Compensation, Cyber Insurance, and more, catering to diverse business needs.
Industries Served:
Small Businesses
Contractors
Non-Profits
Landlords
Professional Services
Restaurants
Technology
Notable Services:
Business Owner's Policy Insurance
Professional Liability Insurance
General Liability Insurance
Workers’ Compensation Insurance
Cyber Insurance
Directors and Officers Insurance
Commercial Umbrella Insurance
Why work with Honig Conte Porrino Insurance Agency Inc.?
HCP combines a blend of tradition and forward-thinking insurance solutions. Their commitment to providing detailed, customer-centric advice at no cost positions them as a reliable partner for both businesses and individuals.
Their tenure in the industry, combined with a hands-on approach to service, ensures that clients are well-informed and adequately protected against various risks.
10. Northwestern Mutual
Northwestern Mutual, with a history spanning over 160 years, is a leader in the financial services sector in New York and beyond, dedicated to enhancing its clients' financial well-being.
This company's philosophy is rooted in the belief that financial security leads to positive life outcomes, enabling clients to feel more confident, secure, and ultimately happier.
Notable Attributes:
Tailored financial strategies
Mutual company benefiting policyowners
Exceptional client retention
Significant dividend payouts
Highest financial strength ratings
Comprehensive service offerings
Key Services:
Financial Planning
Insurance (Life, Disability, Long-term care)
Investments
Private Client Services
Educational Resources on Financial Planning and Investing
Why work with Northwestern Mutual?
Northwestern Mutual is a firm that puts people at its core, ensuring financial plans are not just transactions but are a pathway to achieving life's goals.
Their commitment to personalized service, coupled with an unwavering dedication to financial strength and client benefits, sets them apart as a top-tier financial services provider.
11. Greenpoint Insurance Brokerage
Greenpoint Insurance Brokerage operates from Brooklyn and Warwick, New York, offering a comprehensive range of insurance products and services, designed to meet both personal and commercial needs.
For individuals, Greenpoint provides homeowners, auto, motorcycle, life, and health insurance. For businesses, the brokerage covers general liability, workers' compensation, commercial auto, property, and umbrella insurance.
The company's offerings include business services like tax preparation, notary public, translation services, and assistance with new business formation and payroll.
Key Services:
Personal and Commercial Insurance Lines
Tax Services
Notary Public
Translations
New Business Formation
Payroll Services
Why work with Greenpoint Insurance Brokerage?
Greenpoint Insurance Brokerage provides stable, trusted, and reliable services across a broad spectrum of insurance and business needs. With a strong focus on building relationships and protecting futures, the company tailors its offerings to individual and business clients, ensuring thorough coverage and peace of mind.
Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a New York Insurance Agency & Broker
Reputation and Reliability: Look for agencies with positive reviews and a solid track record. Their ability to handle claims efficiently and support their clients is crucial.
Range of Products: Choose an agency that offers a wide range of insurance products. Your needs might change, and having various options under one roof can be beneficial.
Customer Service: Exceptional customer service, including prompt responses and personalized care, should be a priority. This ensures a smoother experience during times of need.
Expertise and Advice: An agency that provides insightful advice and has expertise in various insurance products can guide you to make better-informed decisions.
Affordability and Value: Compare the costs versus benefits of the policies offered. It's not always about finding the cheapest option, but the one that offers the best value for your investment.
Accessibility: Ease of access to your broker or agent, whether it’s through digital means or in person, can significantly impact your experience.
Local Knowledge: A New York-based agency familiar with the local laws and regulations can offer more tailored advice and coverage options.
What New York Insurance Agency & Brokers Will You Choose?
Choosing the right insurance agency and broker in New York is more than just ticking boxes; it's about finding a partner who can support and protect your interests in every stage of life.
As you navigate through your options, consider not only the services and products they offer but also the values and commitment they bring to their clients. The best choice will be one that aligns with your needs, preferences, and future goals.
Whether you're insuring your home, vehicle, business, or health, the importance of trust and reliability cannot be overstated. Take your time, do your research, and choose a partner that will stand by you when it matters most.
